Wednesday, March 6, 2013
Book Review - “The Encyclopedia of Swedish Punk: 1977-1987” by Peter Jandreus
The
title says it all. The author has taken the best parts of every punk
documentation book that I have seen and combined them into one. If you have
read Ian Glaspar’s “Trapped in a Scene” there is a lot of great historical
stories. Peter Jandreus takes these stories and works them down into a bite
size bit which is in keeping with the encyclopedia format. Frank Manley put
together one of the first national discographies in the form of “Smash the
State”. Jandreus’s comprehensive lists of band releases fills out the band
profiles. And his discography includes a scale for worth of the records which
makes it ideal for record collectors. It is the best of all worlds really with
what has been done in the arena of punk books. Short of writing the amazing Chris
Walter like band biographies, Jandreus has found the perfect in between
collection of great stories and documentation. And they totally remind me of
the old Funk and Wagnells that my parents had, just with punk content. One
advantage to Jandreus’s book over Wikipedia is that some of these bands might
be too small to include in the on-line source. The reason why I bought this book
was because I wanted to do more research on ASTA KASK and I was frustrated by
the hype writing that made up the majority of my web searches on the band. In a
brief read I was able to learn about the important role that the band played in
the Swedish scene by building a studio in their old rehearsal space which they
let any other punk bands use for free to record. You can see how a resource
like this would prove to be super important. And as I flip through this book I
find myself doing more on-line searches to track down bands that I know little
about. In addition, this book organizes everything alphabetically by band which
is the encyclopedia method. This makes it easy to search a band but I wonder if
Ian Glaspar’s method of regional writing isn’t a better method when writing a
national scene account. It is certainly easier to follow the band
intersections. Like all good books this brings up more questions with the answers
and the best review I have read of this book is by Stuart Schrader which draws
some of that out. You can read it on-line at http://stuartschrader.com/writing/book-review-encyclopedia-swedish-punk-1977-1987.
But even with the shortcomings this is the best of its kind that I have read
and a rich and valuable resource for Swedish punk. I hope someone applies this
model to scenes in Japan and Germany and Italy and Finland and anywhere there
is a Bloodstain comp. (Premium Publishing – Sankt Goransgatan 159 / Box 30184 /
SE-104 25 Stockholm / Sweden / www.premiumpublishing.com)
Labels:
-BOOK REVIEWS
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment